Don't try to put words in my mouth. I have not denied that there are legitimate gender dysphoric and abnormal chromosome people. But gender fluid, non-binary and phony for bad reasons is not gender-dysphoria where someone ALWAYS feels that they are the sex opposite their plumbing. As you wrote easy to distinguish with those tells. Words …
Don't try to put words in my mouth. I have not denied that there are legitimate gender dysphoric and abnormal chromosome people. But gender fluid, non-binary and phony for bad reasons is not gender-dysphoria where someone ALWAYS feels that they are the sex opposite their plumbing. As you wrote easy to distinguish with those tells. Words have meaning.
I have no idea how to balance rights that infringe upon the rights of others. That's why we are having this discussion.
All "abnormal chromosome people" are either male or female. "Aneuploidy" is an abnormality in the number of chromosomes in a cell due to loss or duplication. In humans, aneuploidy would be any number of chromosomes other than the usual 46. Any individual with the SRY gene, which enables the formation of testes, is male. The SRY gene is almost always found on the Y chromosome, so the shorthand way of saying how a male can be identified is to say that any individual with a Y chromosome is male. In very rare cases, the SRY gene will have migrated to and be found on the X chromosome which every male has. This is a great resource for understanding what sex is, how it is determined, and what Disorders of Sexual Development are: https://theparadoxinstitute.com
How do we balance the rights of men who "feel" they want to have sex with a woman with the rights of women who do not want to have sex with those men? We have criminal and civil laws and penalties against non-consensual sex.
That's the answer to how to treat individuals who "ALWAYS feel that they are the sex opposite their plumbing." They are objectively, materially, NOT female, no matter how they feel, and should not be treated as if they were female, no matter how they feel.
Don't try to put words in my mouth. I have not denied that there are legitimate gender dysphoric and abnormal chromosome people. But gender fluid, non-binary and phony for bad reasons is not gender-dysphoria where someone ALWAYS feels that they are the sex opposite their plumbing. As you wrote easy to distinguish with those tells. Words have meaning.
I have no idea how to balance rights that infringe upon the rights of others. That's why we are having this discussion.
All "abnormal chromosome people" are either male or female. "Aneuploidy" is an abnormality in the number of chromosomes in a cell due to loss or duplication. In humans, aneuploidy would be any number of chromosomes other than the usual 46. Any individual with the SRY gene, which enables the formation of testes, is male. The SRY gene is almost always found on the Y chromosome, so the shorthand way of saying how a male can be identified is to say that any individual with a Y chromosome is male. In very rare cases, the SRY gene will have migrated to and be found on the X chromosome which every male has. This is a great resource for understanding what sex is, how it is determined, and what Disorders of Sexual Development are: https://theparadoxinstitute.com
Thanks. I mentioned "abnormal chromosome people" with regard to whataboutism with respect to sports where it is not a case of "I identify as".
How do we balance the rights of men who "feel" they want to have sex with a woman with the rights of women who do not want to have sex with those men? We have criminal and civil laws and penalties against non-consensual sex.
That's the answer to how to treat individuals who "ALWAYS feel that they are the sex opposite their plumbing." They are objectively, materially, NOT female, no matter how they feel, and should not be treated as if they were female, no matter how they feel.