3 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Chris Fox's avatar

That is an intellectually disqualifying noise. “Right to exist” is logical nonsense and is used as a distraction. The land has changed hands dozens of times and any claim by Israel to what was recently Palestine is absurd, “Jews lived here thousands of years ago,” who cares?

The issue is not your absurdity, the issue is Israel’s ongoing theft of land, Israel’s wanton butchery of innocent people.

Israel should be occupied by the UN, the settlers removed from the territories.

Expand full comment
Victoria Fidler's avatar

For someone that writes, "let's Champion Objective Reality" you sure do spout a lot of BS. Jews have maintained a presence in the land throughout time. There were Jews and Arabs living there under the British mandate. During the Peel Commission and and later the British mandate Arabs and Jews were offered a partition with each having their own state. All offers then were met with rejection by the Arabs. All additional offers throughout the years have also been rejected by the Arabs. Gaza was left to its own devices in 2005, so much possibility to only end in violence.

Expand full comment
Chris Fox's avatar

Absurd. If Mexico took 2/3 of Texas and offered the remainder, would that be regarded as a good deal?

Yes there were Jews in Palestine and they got along with Arabs.

Until 1948.

Yeah, Gaza was left to its own devices. Blockaded and isolated. And it was Netanyahu who put Hamas in charge of it.

Expand full comment