7 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Peaceful Dave's avatar

When I was a child my mother sent me to summer with country relatives. One summer it was with an aunt who was a piano teacher. At the end of summer, I played in church from the Baptist (Broadman) Hymnal. I went back home to no piano and forgot it. I cannot sight read on any instrument that I play now, ruined by tablature or chord charts.

I play with people who use songbooks with notation and need to work on learning it since I am often limited to playing chords without that ability. For songs with long strings of chords with 3 Major & 3 minor chords with two different chords in each measure at the speeds they play it would be easier to play the melody. I need to work on that since one of my reasons for music is to exercise my brain now that I've retired from my thinking job. The task is complicated by my playing instruments with different tunings, so the notes are in different places on the fretboard. I need to do it even though it is contrary to my goal of being able to play anything I hear or have in my head without paper.

I just looked up figured bass. Good grief!

Expand full comment
Chris Fox's avatar

I used sheet music to learn a piece, classical or rock, many years before I could play live from the sheet music. I think it started with playing some studies by Fernando Sor, Classical Era Spanish composer, pieces that fit under the fingers in mostly low positions, Suddenly I could play from the music at performance speed, and then I could play pieces I was trying for the first time at close to performance speed.

I still use sheet music mostly to learn the pieces, though I almost always rearrange them. The guitarist who inspired me to play, Julian Bream, used too many open strings in his arrangements, whereas I try not to mix fretted and open strings in a scale run unless I need to so I can jump to a distant position.

I can read tabs but I'm used to music notation now.

Expand full comment
Peaceful Dave's avatar

Banjo (old-time) got me partial to open strings. I often play in G & D so DADGBE & DGDGBE are tempting guitar tunings (more open string chords) but while I'm learning I'm sticking to EADGBE.

Expand full comment
Chris Fox's avatar

I've never experimented with alternate tunings. About half of classical pieces tune to bass string to D instead of E but whichever tuning I'm using there are passages where the other would be momentarily more convenient. Now on my Yepes 10-string I always have both.

Jimmy Page (Led Zeppelin) tunes his electric to DADGAD, dad-gad, which is why so many bands covering LZ songs don't sound quite right. Joni Mitchell almost never uses the standard tuning.

One piece I really want to learn uses E♭ A D G B♭ E♮ and it's extremely difficult already because of the tempo, but WOW do I want to learn it:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-kI2dnAAZhA

I would need to get totally serious again, practicing hours every day.

Expand full comment
Peaceful Dave's avatar

Drop D (DADGBE) is probably the most common, and easiest, altered tuning since nothing changes for strings 1-5. Power chord on the 6-4 and interesting bass runs on the 6.

Celtic (DADGAD) is a power chord player's delight and more open ringing tonic and dominant strings when playing in the people's key of D. A bit awkward for other chords.

Open G (DGDGBD) is basically the most common banjo tuning so a banjo player could play a guitar without knowing how to play a guitar. I'm resisting that urge because I want to be an actual guitarist.

As for the piece that you linked, I don't even dream of playing something like that. Good grief!

https://www.scales-chords.com/chord-namer/piano?notes=D%23;A;A%23;D;F;G;A%23&key=&bass=D%23

Expand full comment
Chris Fox's avatar

Wow the Wikipedia entry on figured bass is excellent! That has everything I ever knew about it in one screen.

Expand full comment
Peaceful Dave's avatar

I contribute money annually. It's good for many things not politicized. As always, if it can be politicized, not so much.

Expand full comment